I recently saw Tim Allchin writing about why the church often fails to do the biblical work of counseling. My response was, that’s a good list, Tim, but from my tenure in the biblical counseling world, others need to be considered, explained, and corrected. The following is inclusive of Tim’s work and expanded. The list is roughly in descending order, though admittedly, that is a bit arbitrary. So, let me walk you through these and my reasoning for the descending order concept.
My experience includes a wide variety of ministries (one of the benefits of the blessing of a long life). Pam and I started ministry when I became a youth pastor during the last two years of my divinity degree. Later, we did another two-year stint where 50% of my job was youth, and the other 50% was Christian Education. This was followed by several years as Dean of Men at a Bible College, then seven years of church planting, during which I trained with Jay Adams and began working part-time at CCEF. This flowed into five years of full-time work under contract with CCEF in Atlanta and Macon, associated with First Presbyterian Church. Pastor Jim Baird moved to Miami and asked me to join him, where I served as the counseling pastor. After a stint at the University of Georgia, I completed a postdoctoral certificate in Gerontology; next, I served for seven years as Assistant Professor of Practical Theology at Covenant Seminary, and I also developed the counseling program for Trinity College of the Bible and Theological Seminary, a distance education program. The final block of my career, before retiring, was in Alabama as Sr. Pastor (3 years) and, for twenty-plus years, at Briarwood as Pastor of Counseling and Professor of Biblical Counseling at Birmingham Theological Seminary.
So, through the lens of this diverse ministry experience and my interactions with many churches during these years, I derived this list and its descending order.
1. Neglecting the counseling dimension of the pulpit and SS lectern
I am very much in favor of good exegetically derived expositional preaching. However, good preaching that does not flow into implementation in daily living all too often becomes either an intellectual exercise or a toolbox full of tools without the knowledge of how to use them.
Pauline and Petrine preaching always called disciples to action- implementation. Take 2 Peter 1, for example. Peter displays God’s warehouse in verses 3-4, immediately continues in verse five, “For this reason employ all diligence to develop the list of character traits of 5b-8.
2. Forgetting your pastoral rolodex
Since we are in the Petrine literature, consider 1 Peter 5:1-4. Here he instructs church elders to willingly and selflessly shepherd the flock entrusted to them, promising a crown of glory from the Chief Shepherd when He appears. When I was in seminary, we were taught to keep a Rolodex of all the members of our flock and schedule regular individual visits with them at least quarterly. While the Rolodex has become ancient history, the concept has also become ancient history all too often. These visits create opportunities for conversations that lead to preemptive biblical counseling and help eliminate crisis counseling incidents.
3. Failing to do the preemptive work of discipleship
In many churches, discipleship is a common word, but actual discipleship does not happen. It is often relegated to reading various books together and sharing. I’ve had the privilege, both in the church and in the educational world, to disciple folks. One of the most effective ways has been through supervising internships for budding counselors and counseling students. It’s one-on-one coaching, teaching, and encouragement. The result, in a real sense, is shaping counselors who are also being personally shaped in the process.
4. Not tending the sheep, which is strongly challenged in Scripture.
The book of Ezekiel presents a frightening challenge to those called to shepherd who fail to do so: “Thus says Lord Yahweh, ‘Behold, I am against the shepherds, and I will seek My flock from their hand and make them cease from shepherding the flock” (Ezek. 34:10). The 23rd Psalm tell us how the Lord Shepherds, Jesus displays this in action, and Peter assigns it to the elders. Failing to tend to the counseling needs, leading to green pastures (fresh feeding to strengthen to understand and deal with issues), still waters (of the Word to refresh), to restore the soul (wounded by the angsts of life), walking with them (providing comfort through the valley of the shadow(s) of death, and preparing a table for and with them (like prepping for court) in the presence of their enemies so that they are encompassed by goodness and mercy all their days on earth.
5. Neglecting one-anothering
Several years ago, I penned a small book titled Thirty-Seven Biblical Strategies for a Joyful Marriage. I simply challenge and teach couples how to develop an intentional pattern of practicing the one-another passages in their marriage. Any couple that incorporates these will have a joyful marriage, even when the seas of life rage. I contend this is a treasure chest most pastors and church leaders pass over lightly. In doing so, they miss another preemptive strike on potential counseling issues.
6. Neglecting to enlist the healed for training
When members discover the rich rewards of living lives committed to the glory of God as they emerge from crisis and trauma through godly counseling, they become a resource pool you can draft into service when dealing with cases like what they experienced.
7. Underutilizing the survivors
Believers who have survived childhood abuse, broken families, refugees from war, etc. may be overlooked for service. They should be recruited and trained for ministry. Yes, they may have a tainted past like the gentleman who told me, “I cannot serve as an officer. I was divorced.” I took him to lunch and asked him to explain what happened inhis divorce. He shared that he married at sixteen, before he was a believer, and that the marriage ended before he was twenty, when she started hooking up with a former boyfriend. Several years later, he converted and, by 30, happily married a sweet Christian gal for some twenty years. I asked if there was a way for me to verify the facts, and he agreed. I then walked him through biblical teaching that addressed his situation and asked if he would allow his name to remain on the docket. He agreed, was elected, and served well as an elder.
8. Neglecting God’s warehouse of tools (2pet 1:3-4)
I have already touched on this above, but I will point out the example of Timothy. Paul encourages him to study to show himself approved unto God, then to discipline himself for godliness, and finally, not to be intimidated by older folks who questioned his youth. With these instructions in hand, he dispatched him to pastor the church.
9. Not training people to employ “all diligence” to use God’s tools
Let me continue with Timothy to illustrate here. He was to choose and train leaders, keeping in mind that “All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness.” He then reminds him that through this Word “the servant of God may be thoroughly equipped for every good work.” This told Timothy he could train all kinds of saints for ministry by following his example of studying the Word and discipling himself for godliness (living what he is learning and teaching).
10. Referral is the solution for the church when it comes to counseling.
The argument is that pastors do not have the time to meet with people multiple times. Secondly, it is argued that it is legally safer to refer out; after all, the pastor does not have the clinical knowledge and expertise to diagnose mental illness. So, what does refer out suggest? Well, to answer that, this article says the bottom line is this. It is saying that, unless there is a biomedical medical issue, the Word of God is insufficient.
The Pastor, or the Biblical Counselor, should be the first line of defense. Medical referral, followed by working in concert, may be needful. But skirting the Pastor and Biblical Counselor assumes the needfulness of the medical model of mental illness. And when the outsourcing route is chosen, who will vet the outsource first?
11. Forgetting that healing is not instantaneous (It is progressive sanctification)
Ok, so the outsource signs off on the counselee and returns them to the flock. Now what? Now the pastor (elder or biblical counselor) needs to provide aftercare. Why? Because the Christian life is about progressive sanctification. Secondly. If they have a blip on the radar, these folks need a relationship with an in-house person they trust to help them deal with it.
Conclusion:
All in all, failing to do God’s work God’s way does not glorify God. The church that “turned the world upside down, was not an outsourcing institution. It was an organization that addressed issues from the Word of God, discipled the children of God, developed disciple-makers, and amazed the world with the transforming power of the Gospel flowing out of the lives of God’s people.
